September 22, 2025

Donny Mashiach – CFO Reveals His 90% Client Win Rate Secret

James Kennedy sits down with Donny Mashiach, founder of Warrior GP, to unpack how he’s importing an investment-banking “deal team” model into the fractional CFO world. Donny shares how he consistently closes prospects with a pre-work, presentation-led pitch, how he aligns incentives so everyone wins, and a concrete case study where he unlocked $750k of cash by fixing inventory turns at an eCommerce retailer. They also touch on walking away from “wrong” venture terms, seasonality planning, and why founders should expect their exit to feel personal – and stressful.
The Gross Profit Podcast
The Gross Profit Podcast
Donny Mashiach - CFO Reveals His 90% Client Win Rate Secret
Loading
/

Show Notes

In this episode, James Kennedy sits down with Donny Mashiach, founder of Warrior GP, to unpack how he’s importing an investment-banking “deal team” model into the fractional CFO world. Donny shares how he consistently closes prospects with a pre-work, presentation-led pitch, how he aligns incentives so everyone wins, and a concrete case study where he unlocked $750k of cash by fixing inventory turns at an eCommerce retailer. They also touch on walking away from “wrong” venture terms, seasonality planning, and why founders should expect their exit to feel personal – and stressful.

About Donny Mashiach

Donny began as an entrepreneur (yes, hot-dogs at Wrigley Field), then trained in finance through internships in private equity and hedge funds before moving into investment banking (M&A / capital markets). Those years built a pattern-recognition engine across dozens of businesses – knowledge he now channels through Warrior GP, a fractional CFO platform that pairs US-based CFOs with an offshore analyst bench to deliver strategic finance, FP&A, capital-raise and exit prep for growing companies.

What You’ll Learn

  • The Deal-Team CFO Model: Why splitting strategy & relationships (CFO/MD) from analysis & build (analyst pod) lets fractional CFOs scale quality and speed.
  • How to Win the Pitch: The “do the work first” approach – secure financials under NDA, analyze, and present tailored findings so prospects see value before they sign.
  • Inventory → Cash, Fast: How SKU-level aging (Shopify → Excel automation) reveals dead stock, drives Black Friday liquidation, and freed $750k of trapped cash.
  • Funding Discipline: When to skip a venture round with weak valuation, build with toll-gates, and sell later at a better multiple with less dilution.
  • Aligned Incentives: Structuring retainers and upside so teams behave like owners, not time-card keepers – and clients feel progress, not hours.

Episode Highlights

  • Entrepreneurs are modern-day warriors. Our job is to join their team and help them push through.”
  • Prospects believe what they see—not what you promise. Show them their numbers, their trends, their upside.”
  • “We spotted inventory turns falling from ~5–6 to ~1. Once they saw the SKU-aging, the mandate was obvious—and $750k hit the bottom line.”
  • “Saying no to a low-ball VC round gave the runway to grow into a strategic exit – higher revenue multiple, zero dilution.
  • “Fractional CFOs get stuck doing everything. Split roles like a bank: MD/CFO leads; analysts execute. Throughout (and results) go up.”

More About Warrior GP

At Warrior GP, Donny’s team delivers:

  • Strategic Finance & FP&A: Forecasting, KPI design, pricing/margin work, board & lender reporting.
  • Capital & Exits: Investor decks, diligence readiness, and M&A support grounded in banking-grade materials.
  • Ops Finance Wins: Order-to-cash hygiene, cash-flow modeling, and automations (e.g., Shopify → SKU aging) that convert working capital into cash.
  • Partner Model for CFOs: US-based CFOs can plug into Warrior’s analyst bench and sales process to run a true deal-team practice.

Who should reach out: Founder-led companies ~$2M–$40M revenue (eCommerce/retail, services, SaaS, and other growth SMBs) planning a raise, eyeing an exit, or needing a CFO who brings both banker rigor and operator practicality.

The Gross Profit Podcast

More Episodes

Merushka Chetty

Debbie Rosler – CEO Embezzled $1.5M From His Own Startup

In this episode, James Kennedy sits down with Debbie Rosler, fractional CFO at Burkland, to dig into the uncomfortable but critical topic of waste, fraud and abuse inside venture-backed startups. Drawing on a career that spans investment banking, private equity, Levi Strauss, dot-com startups and a career-defining embezzlement case where a CEO “borrowed” $1.5M from his own company, Debbie walks through exactly how it happened, why the board didn’t catch it, and the practical controls that saved the business. They also explore how SaaS founders can use “two sets of eyes,” approval matrices and even purchase orders with lawyers and contractors – and why phishing, payment-redirection scams and AI deepfakes make 2025 a dangerous time to be casual about controls. James closes by introducing redflag.procurementexpress.com, a 30-second AI QuickBooks scan that flags unusual spending patterns before they blow up into a crisis.

Listen Now »
Merushka Chetty

Nick Bilotta – The Medieval Accounting Trick That Still Works Today

In this episode, James Kennedy sits down with Nick Bilotta, Founder of Bilotta & Co. CPAs, to explore two powerful concepts often misunderstood in the accounting world: fund accounting and financial storytelling. Nick shares why fund accounting – often dismissed as an “old-school” practice – is becoming more relevant than ever for nonprofits, contractors, and organizations that need transparency, donor confidence, and better decision-making. He also breaks down how great accountants don’t just report numbers – they translate financials into narratives that inspire trust, secure funding, and shape an organization’s future. From motorcycle technician to SEC reporting leader to firm owner, Nick’s unconventional journey gives him a unique perspective on the role of modern CPAs, fractional CFOs, and the importance of clarity in financial communication.

Listen Now »
Merushka Chetty

Andy Mellor – The Truth About Fractional CFOs

In this episode, James Kennedy sits down with UK-based portfolio CFO Andy Mellor, founder of Summit17, to tackle a controversial question: what actually makes a “real” fractional CFO? Drawing on Andy’s journey from big corporate finance to PE-backed gym chains and nursery groups, through to running his own packed portfolio practice, they unpack how to separate serious CFOs from title-only pretenders, why great financial models should drive day-to-day decisions (not gather dust in Excel), and how fractional CFOs can build real equity instead of just selling hours. Along the way, Andy shares a live MBO case study where a retiring partner was bought out without private equity and how smart forecasting and cash planning made it possible.

Listen Now »