March 21, 2020

Blasé About Embezzlement? How a Nashville Entrepreneur Lost $300k to a “Loyal” Employee

Robert Hartline talks to James Kennedy about his payroll fraud nightmare. He was baffled when he first came across suspicious numbers on his payroll but soon discovered that a contractor had stolen $300k from his business.
Gross Profit Podcast
The Gross Profit Podcast
Blasé About Embezzlement? How a Nashville Entrepreneur Lost $300k to a “Loyal” Employee
Loading
/

Show Notes

Robert Hartline talks to James Kennedy about his payroll fraud nightmare. He was baffled when he first came across suspicious numbers on his payroll but soon discovered that a contractor had stolen $300k from his business. In this episode, Robert urges listeners to be ruthless about double-checking transactions and verifying facts, and explains why American Greed should be on every business owner’s list of shows to watch.


What Is Absolute Wireless?

Robert started Absolute Wireless 21 years ago and now has approximately 380 people working in the organisation. He never planned to be in retail, but has learned a lot about it and has also learned a lot about sales leadership.

How Did Absolute Wireless Get Defrauded?

If you have ever watched American Greed and you’ve listened to those stories and asked yourself if this could happen to you… well, it could.

There can be somebody in your organisation who is super loyal, at work super early every day, never takes vacations and they are secretly stealing from you!

That’s what happened to Robert a few years ago. His organisation used a company to do their payroll services, which is considered to be best practice by many businesses. Every time he tried to get into the payroll system and take a look at the reports, he had trouble getting access. 

Anyone running a fast-paced business knows that it’s easy to get distracted and not follow-up on everything that needs to be sorted out. He sat down one day and was looking at a cash flow issue and something just didn’t add up. He then used an employee’s login details to get access to these reports he had been looking for and saw a shocking and confusing report. 

There was a man named “Michael” at the top of the list who made $106,000. Rob says that he knows everyone who makes over $100k in the organisation, which is why he knew that there was no way this man should be getting paid so much. After investigating this report some more, he discovered that there were other names on this list that had never worked for him in the past. He messaged his direct contact from the payroll company, and she told him these people had not actually been paid and it’s just an error in the report. Robert knew immediately that was not the case and the next day, he drove down to the payroll office and asked to speak to the manager. As soon as he said that he wanted to know what the actual chances of his data in his reports being mixed up with someone else’s data are, he was told it was impossible.

The FBI were then called as well as their insurance company. Luckily, the payroll company had an Errors and Omissions policy, which essentially means it covers fraud. Robert had no idea he was this protected and thankfully, he got over 300k back in the same week.

Absolute Wireless now has a process where when a payroll is run, all of the reports are compared against each other in order to make sure that everyone has been paid the right amount of money. The woman responsible for defrauding Absolute Wireless had to spend less than a year in prison. 

Robert advises to always trust your gut about who you’re working with. He had an off-putting feeling about this person at the time.

We hope you enjoyed this brief episode of The Gross Profit Podcast!

Don’t forget to follow Robert on Twitter and check out his blog to learn about sales leadership management!

Key links 

CallProof Blog 

Absolute Wireless

American Greed 

This podcast is tagged under:

The Gross Profit Podcast

More Episodes

Merushka Chetty

Hillel Steiner – This Israeli CFO Secret Could Double Your Profits

This week James sits down with Hillel Steiner, founder of ProfitUp Financials and a fractional CFO based in Israel, to discuss the surprising advantages of working with international finance talent. Together, they dive into the differences between U.S. and Israeli business cultures, what founders often get wrong about funding, and how having a strong financial strategy can be the difference between staying stuck and scaling up.
Hillel also walks through a real-life case study of a BI company stuck in a high-revenue, low-profit cycle – and how he helped them transform by refocusing their service model and aligning their team more efficiently.
Stick around to the end for a massive bonus offer from Hillel that’s perfect for growing service-based companies.

Listen Now »
Merushka Chetty

Patrick Arnold – 7M Sales, Zero Profit: The Fix 

This week James sits down with Patrick Arnold, Director of Client Advisory Services at Elliott Davis, to explore the power of Client Advisory Services (CAS) and its game-changing impact on business profitability. Patrick shares an engaging case study of how he helped a golf cart business in South Carolina go from stagnant growth to seven-figure annual distributions – all by optimizing inventory, restructuring financial processes, and leveraging technology for smarter decision-making.
They also dive into the role of CAS in modern accounting, the evolution of public accounting firms to include more strategic, forward-thinking advisory, and how business owners can unlock hidden cash flow by better managing working capital.

Listen Now »
Merushka Chetty

Chris May – Fake CFOs Exposed: How to Spot the Difference

This week James sits down with Chris May, founder and CEO of Quadrant Advisory, to explore what separates real CFO strategy from everyday accounting. From turning around a $50M political consulting firm to navigating tricky incumbent finance teams, Chris shares practical advice for business leaders and fractional CFOs alike.
Together, they unpack key finance tools like sensitivity analysis, working capital management, and how to tell whether your books are just “done” – or actually useful. Chris also walks us through his own acquisition of a bookkeeping SaaS and what it taught him about keeping services laser-focused.

Listen Now »